Transfer station

Shelter Island Recycling Transfer Station

34 N Menantic Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964-1000

At the gate

Type Transfer station
Address 34 N Menantic Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964-1000
County Suffolk County
Phone 631-749-1090
Last checked Oct 21, 2026

Hours, accepted materials and fees have not been confirmed yet. Call the scale house at 631-749-1090 before you go.

Nearby with confirmed hours or fees: Sag Harbor Transfer Station , North Sea Waste Management Facility .

Facility facts

Ownership Public
Owner Town of Shelter Island
Owner type Municipal
Operational status Active
Permitted activities HHW collection facility - permit, Transfer facility - less than 50 tpd - registration
Waste types accepted (per permit) Commingled Paper & Containers, Commingled Plastics, Concrete, Construction & Demolition Debris, Electronics, Emergency Authorization Waste (Storm Debris), Glass, Leaves & Grass, MSW (Residential/Institutional & Commercial), Metals (Ferrous & Non-Ferrous), Sand, Tree Debris, White Goods
Permit and registry IDs (2)
Permit number 52-0282
Authorization expires 11/17/2023

Suggest a correction

Hours changed, fees went up, gate moved? Tell us and we will check it. Own or manage Shelter Island Recycling Transfer Station? Use the same form to claim it.

Suggest a correction for Shelter Island Recycling Transfer Station

Nearby facilities

Transfer station

Sag Harbor Transfer Station

Sag Harbor, NY · 6.8 mi away

Hours
Mon 8:30 AM-4:00 PM · Tue 8:30 AM-4:00 PM · …
Fees
Household garbage in green Town bags: large 5 bags $18.25, small 5 bags $10.25; other items per the Waste Management Fee Schedule
Transfer station

North Sea Waste Management Facility

North Sea, NY · 9.6 mi away

Hours
Mon 8:30 AM-4:00 PM · Tue 8:30 AM-4:00 PM · …
Fees
Household garbage in green Town bags: large 5 bags $18.25, small 5 bags $10.25; other items per the Waste Management Fee Schedule

Sources: data.ny.gov (facility record, phone, facility facts and permit and registry IDs; fetched Oct 21, 2026) . Registry figures are as of Apr 21, 2026. Facility details were last checked on Oct 21, 2026.